Lincoln Falls was named in honor of President Abraham Lincoln during the Civil war. It was at this time that a post office was established as well as two saw mills and a few homes. A general store and a Wesleyan Methodist church completed the village.

Early history records indicate the Towanda Path and the Genesee Road passed through the heart of Lincoln Falls. It was used as early Indian paths and later as a main route by emigrants traveling from neighboring sourthern states to the valley of the Genesee River in New York State. (This is documented in Indian Paths of Pennsylvania: No. 112, p.161.)

The Falls also figured prominently as an audio signal for slaves seeking freedom during the era of the Underground Railroad. One path leading to Canada followed along Elk Creek from Hillsgrove to the juncture with Kings Creek. At this point a lovely waterfall is evident. Hearing that sound, the travelers knew to turn toward the left to a safe house a short distance away.

People with early roots in Sullivan County can find additional information and many artifacts at the Sullivan County Historical Museum in Laporte. There is also an Underground Railroad museum established in Montrose PA. Contact us at the lodge for further information.